Tug owners navigate changing global challenges

Owner consolidation

Also impacting global and regional towage markets is the recent consolidation of ownership, with Boluda Towage, strengthened by investment from Mediterranean Shipping Co, becoming the world’s largest tugboat operator through acquisitions.

In Australia, multiple ownership changes within 18 months have compressed a fragmented market towards a two- or three-operator national outcome, said the brokers.

In Latin America, SAAM Towage is emerging as a potential global-scale player, “while the Americas market broadly remains one of the most structurally competitive,” they said.

“Across Europe and the Middle East, the pool of willing sellers has shrunk with availability, not ambition, being the binding constraint for acquisitive majors.”

But, the integration of major towage groups is generating commercial backlash across multiple regions, from northern European shipowners to Latin American cargo interests, which are uncomfortable with concentration and conflicts of interest.

“Independent operators from northern Europe to Australia are finding this reputational opening translates into direct client approaches,” said the ACL brokers.

“Fuel costs have more than doubled in some markets”

“The response from mid-sized operators has been to form co-operative network alliances, pooling geographic reach across regions to replicate the multi-port packages that consolidated majors offer.”

One example is the formation and growth of Tug Network Team, which combines the fleets of Canada’s Group Ocean, Sulnorte in Brazil and Chilean owner CPT Towage, and Germany’s Fairplay Towage.

There is also a distinction between equity-funded and debt-funded operators that is impacting market competition.

“Some players are knowingly signing long-term contracts at a loss, which is viable on borrowed money but not on equity,” said the ACL brokers.

“This distorts competitive pricing in smaller harbour-tug segments and pushes rational players toward larger, more complex vessel classes where returns are more defensible.”

Despite industry consolidation, the broader market remains highly fragmented. Port authorities and family-owned operators still control most of the global tonnage.

Sustainability

Pressures on owners to reduce emissions while remaining competitive and sustainable have lessened in the past 18 months, but still require addressing.

“The commercial fragility of green initiatives has been exposed and tested,” said the ACL brokers. “Biofuel programmes that worked under subsidy have collapsed without it.”

For example, in the UK, operators were fuelling tugs with hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO), but when government grants ended, HVO adoption stopped nearly simultaneously.

Some owners are using carbon offsetting at a fraction of the cost of building a single electric-powered tug to demonstrate their sustainability.

“It is pragmatic, but it is not transformation and there is still a long way to go,” said the brokers.

“The technology picture is clarifying even as the commercial case remains elusive. Battery-electric propulsion is emerging as the credible near-term pathway for harbour towage,” they added.

Battery costs have fallen significantly, maintenance savings are being realised, and crew conditions are measurably better, but limited port investment in charging infrastructure is constraining tug newbuilding orders.

“Where progress is happening, it is often driven by port-authority commitment, rather than operator conviction or client demand,” said the brokers.

S&P market trends

Investments in assets have stalled and tugboat valuations have risen sharply in the past three years. Vessels purchased in 2024 are worth more today than at acquisition.

Five-year-old tugs are priced close to newbuild prices, which have risen around 30% over those five years.

“Second-hand values are at historically anomalous levels,” said the ACL brokers. “The market is thin on supply and long on demand, and there is no meaningful correction in sight.”

Operators are responding by extending asset lives. Vessel lifecycles are stretching from 20 to 25 years, as some owners resist the capital cost of replacement and clients are reluctant to accommodate the significantly higher day rates that new tonnage requires.

“Deep retrofit and life extension are emerging as genuinely competitive alternatives to new construction, particularly for well-performing hulls in the 15-to-25-year range,” said the brokers.

“Newbuild strategies are diverging. Well-capitalised operators in Europe are ordering speculatively ahead of contracts to enable rapid deployment and win short-notice tenders, a shift from contract-led procurement,” they added.

In the offshore and terminal sectors, owners are ordering small numbers of tugs to cover signed contracts and committed revenue.

But, some industry trends are driving owners to order newbuilds. Bollard pull requirements are drifting upward, with 70 to 80 tonnes becoming a minimum in more ports worldwide.

Capital is becoming accessible again for tugs with twin diesel engines, while the supply of ice-class tugs has tightened and lease-to-own and bareboat structures are gaining traction among smaller operators.

“Operators best positioned to navigate the global market share recognisable traits: diversification that averages out regional shocks; financial discipline that resists overpaying in a seller’s market; and a pragmatic, rather than ideological, approach to decarbonisation,” said the ACL brokers.

“The next cycle may reveal those who have built these capabilities from those who have relied on a rising tide,” they added.

Riviera will host TUGTECHNOLOGY ‘27 in Rotterdam, the Netherlands, 19-20 May 2027. Use this link for more information and to register.