The deepening recession and global financial crisis are now having an adverse affect on the ropax and short sea freight-only ferry markets, hitting owners, operators and shipyards alike
In recent months, ferry routes have been cut back, companies have gone into liquidation and mergers are increasingly being considered; desperate times demand drastic measures in order to consolidate and survive. Companies are coming to realise that the time to act is now, since no light is seen at the end of the tunnel until well into 2010 at least.
Specialist construction shipyards, mainly in Europe, have over the past few years welcomed a plethora of contracts for new ropax vessels, several of which are the largest ever seen on particular routes. Many of these orders are intended to replace older ferries which do not meet Solas 2010 regulations for the passenger industry. There has been a similar surge in contracting of shortsea freight-only ferries as green trading issues take greater hold, encouraging a shift from all-road to combined road-sea activity.
With the onset of the credit crunch, newbuilding investment has come to a sudden halt and, in the current circumstances, is seen as an unwanted burden on expenditure. For their part, ship owners and builders have never been more committed to this sector, but the perceived greed and reckless gambling of money by an irresponsible banking profession has brought the passenger and freight industry to its knees. Services have been cut and existing hulls laid up as credit lines have dried and cargo demand has evaporated. Uncertainty over the future is killing confidence in the current climate.
Around 80 ropax units are still officially on order worldwide, but some of these will probably not be built. Attempts by owners to renegotiate newbuilding prices are proving fruitless at this stage, as shipbuilders can stand firm on a strong orderbook. Pressure is increasing, however, and it is inevitable that shipyards will have to yield ground on ships for delivery from 2010 onwards.
Breaks in the newbuilding supply chain, where credit is suddenly withdrawn, bringing receivership in its wake, is an increasing problem. This is perhaps a nightmare scenario for shipbuilders as it may give the shipowner the opportunity to cancel contracts legally.
There are in any case increasing reports of cancellations, and more seem certain to follow. The parlous state of Poland’s shipbuilding industry was brought into perspective by the enforced sale by auction of the Szczecin and Gdynia complexes. Unity Line, a subsidiary of Polsteam, cancelled two 300 passenger, 3,000 lane metre roro vessels originally ordered from Szczecin in 2007, with delivery due in December 2010 and May 2011. While committed to resurrecting these contracts when the recession ends, Unity Line indicates that the shipyard’s uncertain future made cancellation an easier option.
More southerly European yards have also felt the impact of the downturn. A ropax was recently cancelled at Navantia, Spain, by Acciona Trasmediterranea, for instance. Originally due for delivery in May 2010 it was one of three remaining 3,500 lane metre vessels; the other two will still be built.
Negotiations on ‘troublesome’ contracts are, if cancellation is not an option, likely to result in compromises involving delayed delivery from six months to a year. It is perhaps ironic that larger ferries under construction in Spain and Italy often suffer delivery delays in the normal course of construction, with owners invoking compensation or penalty clauses. Now some owners are happy to delay delivery legally.
This situation is fraught with problems, however. Such delays will play havoc with shipyard production and could, to a degree, undermine the prospects of yards securing new business.
Until recently, freight orientated roro newbuildings were considered relatively ‘safe’, but the domino impact of lack of credit has now spread to this sector. This is largely due to the rapid collapse in manufacturing, with unprecedented falls in the volumes of rolling plant and machinery using seaborne trade. There are some pockets of resistance where traffic levels are still holding up well and it would be wrong to paint a picture of total gloom. Nevertheless, survival is currently the order of the day, with the priority being to ride out the recession in the hope that it is short lived.
If anything, the biggest threat is faced by the shipyards. Owners are being squeezed for liquidity and are effectively having the postponement or cancellation of newbuilding contracts forced upon them to improve deteriorating balance sheets. The resale of abandoned contracts is not a realistic option for shipbuilders, as large ropax vessels are generally built to suit specific routes and port infrastructure. Many owners are covered by refund guarantees, making cancellation the tempting way out of the dilemma.
Pleas to governments for more shipyard aid are under serious consideration, purely because of the looming unemployment catastrophe. Some aid is likely to be granted but will it be enough?
The recent German economic package has included shipbuilding aid and resulted in a Ä180 million loan being extended to Wadan Yards by Deutsche Bank and KfW Ipex Bank, which effectively prevented the bankruptcy of the former Aker yards in Wismar and Warnemünde. Wismar is currently building two large 5,500 lane metre ropax ferries for Stena Line, with deliveries due in February and July 2010.
While new business has reduced to a trickle, there has been some activity. Another gas fuelled ferry has been ordered by Fosen Namsos Sjø from Fiskerstrand, for example. The Norwegian yard will carry out final completion, with delivery in 2011, but hull and some outfitting will be undertaken by Western Shipyard, Klaipeda, in continuation of an existing and fruitful agreement.
The situation is marginally better for short sea freight vessels than the ropax market. Grimaldi announced nine new routes for 2009 and currently has nine 3,800-4,000 lane metre roro ships on order in South Korea specifically for such trades. Deliveries start from 2010.
The shortsea freight roro orderbook is, in fact, at its strongest for years, standing at 95 vessels. There are, though, likely to be cancellations in the months ahead. Already, Messina of Italy has pulled out of contracts for two 3,600 lane metre ferries originally agreed with Gemak, Turkey, for delivery in 2011 and 2012 and has broken off negotiations with Samsung for more units. The owner indicates it will ride out the recessionary storm with its current fleet and will be ready to order in two years time when prices have hopefully reduced.
Lower prices will be a key factor in any upturn in ordering when market recovery comes along. However, there appears to be still no willingness on the part of shipyards to consent to such reductions at this stage. PST
Events
© 2026 Riviera Maritime Media Ltd.