Asked what structural changes have affected the OSV sector since the first issue of OSJ, leading figures in the offshore vessel market had differing views on whether there has been a structural change in the sector.
Ian Perrott, former co-managing director of ER Offshore, said he didn’t believe that the structure of the OSV market had changed fundamentally in the last 10–15 years. “The oil majors and the state oil companies still remain at the top of the food chain. Construction companies continue to operate their own fleet of OSVs but supplement this with chartered-in tonnage as and when required,” he told OSJ.
“There are arguably now a larger number of smaller charterers/contractors than 15–16 years ago who operate in the subsea and survey markets and who contract vessels for project-specific charters,” said Mr Perrott.
“If there is one marked change from 15–16 years ago, it is that, back in 1998, the fibre-optic cable market was in full flow and chartered a significant number of offshore vessels worldwide to support many aspects of the subsea cablelaying business.
“That demand came crashing down in the early part of the 2000s. Today, we have seen OSVs being taken up, albeit in limited numbers, to support the embryonic offshore renewable industry. However, this industry itself now appears to be struggling, and only time will tell what its real future will be.”
For his part, Børge Nakken, vice president – technology and development at Farstad, said he saw the reorientation of the industry towards deeper water and harsher environments as a structural change of sorts.
As exploration and production activity moves into new areas, security has also become an issue in some areas, said Mr Nakken. “There is increased activity in political unstable areas and areas where you need to take account of safety and issues such as pirate attacks.
In a sense, he said, there has also been a structural increase in bureaucracy, increased financial risk and a rapid increase in operational expenses, which increased day rates do not always compensate for. Greater focus on safety and the environmental footprint of vessel operations – which is good – has, however, led to significantly increased requirements for documentation, increased bureaucracy, more vetting of vessels – sometimes too much – and a lack of standardisation between the different vetting regimes.
Arnstein Eknes, segment director – special ships, business development at classification society DNV GL, said he believed that the industry definitely had gone through structural change in the last decade. “One structural trend affecting owners of OSVs is the entry of so-called marine contracting companies,” he said. “These companies typically build the offshore installations for the oil and gas companies and don’t just operate vessels but also involve their engineers in designing the entire operation.
“Some big players have invested in offshore vessels – but instead of operating the ships immediately, they sell them back to their bank and then lease them back for operation, in order to see a quick return on investment. Many smaller companies have merged to form larger ones. Alternatively, smaller operators use professional management companies to operate their fleet,” he said.
“The OSV sector also has a range of dedicated design houses working closely with both owners and charterers. Advanced system integration is a key challenge when building new offshore vessels today, so each yard will purchase more of the equipment from dedicated suppliers for OSVs than is the case for most other merchant ship types.”
One area where there definitely has been structural change is in the supply chain for the OSV industry – that is, among shipbuilders active in the market and companies manufacturing equipment for them. The last decade has seen consolidation in both, with fewer independent yards and fewer independent designers, a growing number of enginebuilders and equipment manufacturers who also design vessels and consolidation among equipment suppliers. Even so, there are a number of independent vessel designers who continue to flourish: Guido Perla & Associates in the US is one; Skipsteknisk and Marin Teknikk in Norway are others.
1999 saw the former Ulstein Group design and equipment activities sold to Vickers plc, leaving the shipyard in the hands of the Ulstein family. The long-established Vickers business had seen many changes itself, including the hiving off of the naval shipbuilding activities, so when Vickers acquired Ulstein Group, it already had a portfolio of marine equipment. Integration of the various product activities was underway as Vickers Ulstein Marine Systems when Rolls-Royce bought Vickers plc and the modern era of UT design started. The basic philosophy remained the same – offering offshore vessel designs that meet or anticipate the requirements of the market, together with an ever more comprehensive range of equipment and systems. 2014 saw the UT design celebrate its 40th anniversary.
Ownership of shipyards specialising in offshore vessels has also changed a great deal in the last decade, and it has become increasingly difficult for European yards to compete with those in China. Indian yards were briefly very popular with owners based in Europe, but a reputation for late delivery and lack of support from the Indian Government hasn’t helped their cause.
In Norway, Vard, nowadays a Fincantieri company, designs and builds large numbers of offshore vessels. The company listed on the main board of the Singapore Exchange on 12 November 2010 with Fincantieri Oil & Gas SpA, a wholly owned subsidiary of Fincantieri, as its majority shareholder. The company’s designs date back to 2000, when it established its own inhouse design company. It delivered the first example of a vessel built to its own design in 2004 and sold its first design and equipment packages to yards outside the group in 2007. The company became part of STX and changed its name to STX OSV in 2010, only for the name to change again in 2013 with Fincantieri’s involvement. Meanwhile, and as highlighted elsewhere in this special supplement, Ulstein Group set about developing a completely new range of offshore vessel designs. Unlike Vard and Ulstein, Kleven does not also design vessels, but it has been spectacularly successful in the last few years and has a significant orderbook that should see it through any downturn as a result of the oil price crash.
Nowadays, Chinese yards hold the greatest share of the worldwide platform supply vessel (PSV) orderbook for vessels of in excess of 4,000 tonnes deadweight, with Fujian Mawei and COSCO Guangdong heading the list of builders of PSVs of this size. Although not well known as offshore vessel builders Japanese yards have been picking up more orders in recent years whilst orders for Japanese yards’ staple fare – such as bulk carriers and other, larger ocean-going vessels – have been in short supply.
An order boom in the US in the last three to four years saw yards such as Eastern Shipbuilding pick up a significant number of PSVs for US owners and complete a series of PSVs for Boldini in Brazil – orders that were won partly as a result of small shipbuilding grants that enabled it to enhance its facilities and partly as a result of it gaining access to Title XI loan guarantees. Polish yards have also been enjoying more success in the offshore vessel sector in recent years, among them Remontowa Shipbuilding, but in the 3,000–4,000 dwt category, Chinese yards such as Sinopacific Zhejiang, Fujian Southeast, Fujian Mawei, Guangzhou Hangtong and Xiamen SB also predominate. The small PSV segment sees a much wider range of yards building vessels. It includes ETP Brazil, Sinopacific Zhejiang, Master Boat Builders in the US, Larsen & Toubro (India), NGV Tech (Malaysia), Zamil Offshore (Saudi Arabia), Damen Song Cam (Vietnam), Pipavav Shipyard (India), C&C Boat (US), Simek (Norway), Keppel Nantong and Fujian Mawei (both China) and Grandweld (Dubai).
Unlike the PSV segment, which is dominated by low cost yards in China, the anchor-handling tug/supply (AHTS) vessel segment has a much wider range of yards active in it. The AHTS vessel building segment is also much smaller overall, except in the <8,000 bhp category, where a large number of vessels continue to be ordered for owners in Southeast Asia. Larger anchor handlers remain primarily the preserve of more sophisticated yards, but in the 12,000–16,000 bhp segment, Chinese yards again hold the bulk of orders. Moreover, whereas in the past almost all of the AHTS vessels on order in Chinese yards would have been overseas designs, yards such as Sinopacific have developed – and are now building – their own designs. The 8,000–12,000 bhp segment is also dominated by Chinese yards, among them ASL Shipyard in Guangdong, Guangxin Shipbuilding, COSCO Guangdong, Nantong Tongshun and Sinopacific Zhejiang, but a number of yards in other countries have also played an important role. OSJ