LR2 tankers, VLCCs and Suezmaxes appear to be the segments most heavily congested by the latest newbuilding wave, which now seems to have crested, according to a new shipbroking analysis
Optima Shipping Services said in a recent report that a clearer picture of tanker supply emerges when the current orderbook is measured against vessels that could potentially exit the fleet as recycling candidates, defined as ships aged 15 years and above.
The analysis shows that the LR2 orderbook, as a share of this segment of the fleet, currently stands at 111%, while the ratios are also high for VLCCs and Suezmaxes, at 73% and 72%, respectively. These shares are measured in dwt terms.
A reading above 100% means that the tonnage on order exceeds the entire fleet old enough to be considered a realistic demolition candidate, Optima explained.
The combined Aframax and LR2 ratio falls to 41%, as the Aframax segment has a more balanced relationship between its orderbook and older vessels. The combined reading treats Aframaxes and LR2s as a single crude-capable pool, since LR2s can be deployed in dirty trading.
“An LR2 can trade clean or go dirty, so capacity migrates into Aframax employment, and for many owners that flexibility is the investment case rather than a feature of the hull.”
Focusing solely on LR2s, Optima said around 10% of the fleet is more than 20 years old, while 32% is under five years old.
“Scrap every LR2 aged 15 and over and the orderbook would still not be covered,” Optima noted.
Commenting on the high VLCC and Suezmax ratios, Optima said both segments look heavily supplied, although they have a significant pool of vessels that could potentially be recycled.
“The VLCC carries an extra variable in the shadow fleet: 982 tankers listed as sanctioned, around 17% by dwt, rising to some 1,400 vessels and 25% once broader nexus tonnage is counted. Mainstreamed or beached matters more here than the orderbook does,” Optima highlighted.
MR and LR1 orderbooks, as a percentage of vessels aged 15 years and above, now stand at lower levels of 35% and 22%, respectively.
Meanwhile, tanker demolition reached 1.7M dwt in the first half of 2026, 47% below the 10-year average annualised level. More than 60% of the tonnage scrapped was sanctioned tonnage.
“Nobody beaches a serviceable ship at these values. The valve opens only after rates have fallen, so it cushions a trough rather than preventing one,” Optima said.
Has the wave crested?
However, the current newbuilding wave is showing signs of fatigue, the analysis found.
Optima Shipping Services said shipowners contracted around 70M dwt of tankers in the first half of 2026. Only two full years since 1973 have recorded higher volumes, and this was achieved in just six months.
Optima data shows that roughly 150 VLCCs were ordered, together with more than 75 Suezmaxes, with the latter up 130% year on year.
The oil tanker orderbook now stands at close to a quarter of fleet capacity, a 15-year high, while the crude tanker orderbook, at 129.2M dwt, is the largest in tonnage terms in roughly 50 years.
“The wave has crested, though, and that is not yet in most commentary,” Optima said.
Focusing on VLCCs, the brokerage said contracts numbered 39 in February, 32 in March, 18 in May, 22 in June and six in July. Estimated investment value fell from US$4.7Bn to US$0.7Bn over the same period.
“The tonnage is committed either way, but the ordering itself has largely stopped,” the analysts added.
Ordering made sense
Optima’s analysis also showed why newbuilding investments have made economic sense.
The five-year-old-to-newbuilding price ratio stands at 122%, compared with 82% in 2023, 88% in 2024 and 94% in 2025.
“On sticker price, the yard is the cheaper route to tonnage, and that, rather than a view on 2030, is what most of this wave is,” Optima said.
What it costs is time. The US$28.5M saved on a VLCC comes at the cost of three to four years during which the ship earns nothing. At US$60,000 per day net – below the level at which the one-year time charter has traded at any point this year – the five-year-old vessel earns roughly US$75M before the newbuilding lifts a barrel.
“The yard offers a lower price and a longer wait, and at today’s values the wait is the dearer of the two.”
Events
© 2026 Riviera Maritime Media Ltd.